Whay is Reasonable cost to replace head gasket.

90

Asked by twilson10926 Jul 25, 2012 at 10:11 PM about the 2004 Chevrolet Monte Carlo LS FWD

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

Car never overheated until today. Pulled car off road when I saw the gauge go to 3/4. By time I shut
down the vehicle it was in red zone and engine overheat light came on. Total time less than 2 minutes.
Shop says I have blown head gasket. Is this possible? Car went from cold to overheat in less than 8
minutes. What is reasonable cost to repair?

19 Answers

24,735

If the shop is right and you blew the gasket you would, ballpark, have $1000 to $1400 range. It does seem unlikely, but possible that you took out the head gasket in this short of time. I would get a second opinion to make sure.

7 people found this helpful.
90

Thank you so much Aztec. I am taking it to another shop. They said that sometimes the intake manifold gasket is the problem and that gets misdiagnosed for a head gasket. The first shop did the gas leakage test and said it turned colors. Could the intake manifold gasket cause the same reaction?

4 people found this helpful.
24,735

Yes it can. Sounds like the second shop you took it to has a better handle on your issue.

3 people found this helpful.
5,305

yea the intake gaskets are common leak on gm v6

3 people found this helpful.
90

Aztec and Kevin, I very much appreciate your input and expertise. The intake gasket would be much less expensive to repair. The first shop wanted 3000 dollars to repair and with that they included a new radiador, because although they found nothing wrong with it they said it couldnt be tproperly cleaned, Also a new thermostat and plugs and wires, oil cange also. Does all that seem right and neccessary.

4 people found this helpful.
24,735

Just the fact that they didn't find anything wrong with your radiator and they still want to replace it is reason enough to not give them your business. Any good radiator shop will clean the cores on a radiator for about $175. It's easy to check the flow of a radiator. Shouldn't be any guess work there. With an intake gasket job it is always a good idea to change oil. It is also a good time to change plugs if they are anywhere close to 75,000 miles. Thermostat is a good idea. Wires also probably a good idea, again depending on mileage.

2 people found this helpful.
115

hey aztec, i have a chevy malibu 1997 with 175,400 miles, all highway. my car started throwing anti freeze up the reservoir cap, i took it to a local mechanic and he said it was water pump, when i left lot it had same previous issue again, i was told to put a new cap on it because cap might no be holding tight anymore, me not knowing much did it and said ok. i then took it to another shop because it had same issue, i was told they fixed a fan relay , i took car with and then it broke down super far away, spilled anti freeze on ground and behind engine, i poured more a/c in it and it would spill straight down, i had it towed to shop again and was told to leave it there, he said he changed thermostat, a sensor and flushed radiator and installed 2 hoses since they were broken, i picked up car today and its still over heating, i called mechanic and said it has to be head gasket, whats your opinion on that and how much you think im looking at,

8 people found this helpful.

Honestly the head gaskets would have been my first thought but when the first time it shot fluid up it would make me think to look for other leaks or find out if some how air has gotten into your lines but as for the first problem it was your head gaskets by the sounds of it and no shop likes to deal with head gaskets at lest not for cheap that's why I did my own

55

I paid 435.69 for parts and a few tools I didn't already have. This was on a 2001 Malibu 3.1, 155,230 miles. Tack on the rental car, still had to go to work and the total came to $710.79. It took me a total of 10 hours over a 4 day period. After puting the upper intake on I discovered it was cracked at 4 of the 6 bolt holes, cost 80.00 at salvage yard. I fault the shop which did the 1st intake repair ( 75, 000 miles) I know better now. .

2 people found this helpful.
80

I have a as Monte Carlo it is leaking oil around the oil pan I think it's the gasket but I also see the manifuel there what can it be and how much am I looking to pay ?

8 people found this helpful.
20

I have a 2003 Monte carlo 3400 and tonight it started running rough and the engine light was on. NEVER got hot but when I shut it off and tried to start it the motor only clicked so I jumped the motor, It did run rough and noticed a odd smell and looked to see a bunch of white smoke out the exhaust so I shut it down real quick, I looked at the oil and it was clean with no anti freeze mixed however I started it back up and it blooms white smoke out the pipe could this be a intake gasket burning through the cylinders or do you feel its a head gasket failure as well. It has 180k on the clock and I have no idea when the intake gasket was last changed or if ever we just got it a couple of months ago

2 people found this helpful.

Aztec I have a 2004 Monte Carlo it over heats and it leaks anti freeze. I have o issues with the radiator and head gaskets were replaced two years ago the leak is coming from the top and its by the thermostats that we replaced already its cold and heater doesn't run what can be the problem guy told us the housing maybe cracked it shuts off from time to time but starts right back up please help me email is martyswillis@gmail.com

Did a 2005 Monte Carlo head gasket new head bolts and new exhaust bolts, new water pap new spark plugs and wires $628, $300 was labor pay to a friend

there are some people on here that dont need to give advice. firstly 175 to clean a radiator lol you can probably buy a brand new one for that much so why have the old one clean, thermostats always need to be replaced when a car over heats, it a important and inexpensive part to change, plugs and wire dont need to be changed unless there is a misfire issue.Bad head gasket could have caused the car to over heat or a water pump also. how often where you checking your coolant? you cant drive a 20+ yr old car like a brand new one, you have to pop the hood every now and then and check fluyids. On the 3.1 after you take off everything to change the lower intake gaskets theres really not much more to get the heads off since on that car you have to remove valve covers because the intake is made into the head like the old ford fe motors. I just did one of these and both the head gasket and intake gasket was leaking.

Your Answer:

Monte Carlo

Looking for a Used Monte Carlo in your area?

CarGurus has 193 nationwide Monte Carlo listings starting at $3,500.

ZIP:

Own this car?

Share your experience with others.

2004 Chevrolet Monte Carlo

Review another car

CarGurus Experts

  • #1
    James Sparrow
    Reputation
    1,050
  • #2
    tenspeed
    Reputation
    990
  • #3
    John Saffrahn
    Reputation
    720
View All

Know more, shop wisely

Search

Related Models For Sale

Used Chevrolet Impala
230 Great Deals out of 3,885 listings starting at $1,551
Used Ford Mustang
986 Great Deals out of 19,640 listings starting at $1,500
Used Chevrolet Silverado 1500
4,255 Great Deals out of 123,289 listings starting at $1,999
Used Chevrolet Corvette
791 Great Deals out of 14,581 listings starting at $1,000
Used Chevrolet Tahoe
1,300 Great Deals out of 35,067 listings starting at $1,550
Used Buick Regal
48 Great Deals out of 696 listings starting at $2,795
Used Pontiac Grand Prix
202 listings starting at $2,095
Used Ford F-150
6,534 Great Deals out of 167,530 listings starting at $1,199
Used Chevrolet Malibu
988 Great Deals out of 24,268 listings starting at $600
Used GMC Sierra 1500
1,964 Great Deals out of 71,403 listings starting at $1,900

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use. Content will be removed if CarGurus becomes aware that it violates our policies.