Summary

• With 94 currently listed for sale near New York, NY and an average price of $11,728.00, 30.9% of 2017 Subaru Legacies for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.

• Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2017 Subaru Legacy 4.85 / 5 stars.

• 73.4% of 2017 Legacy models on CarGurus are accident free.

• The 2017 Subaru Legacy is praised for its all-wheel drive, impressive fuel efficiency, and high safety ratings, along with a comfortable interior and user-friendly technology.

Why it stands out

The 2017 Subaru Legacy stands out in the midsize sedan market for its standard all-wheel drive, making it an excellent choice for buyers in regions with inclement weather. Its reputation for safety is bolstered by numerous high safety ratings, and the comfortable interior is complemented by various user-friendly technological features. Additionally, the Legacy's fuel efficiency is particularly commendable, which appeals to budget-conscious consumers. Despite its strengths, some critics mention that the styling may feel a bit bland compared to rivals like the Honda Accord or Toyota Camry, but the unique value proposition of all-wheel drive at this price point gives it a competitive edge.

Other model years to consider

• 2018 Subaru Legacy

  • Average price: $12,570.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 36.1%
  • User rating: 5 / 5
  • Total listings: 97

• 2024 Subaru Legacy

  • Average price: $22,303.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 41.0%
  • User rating: 4.75 / 5
  • Total listings: 105

• 2016 Subaru Legacy

  • Average price: $9,257.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 26.5%
  • User rating: 5 / 5
  • Total listings: 83

This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from March 31, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.